Theresa May Announces New Powers to Tackle Terrorist Attacks

Theresa May, the Home Secretary, this week will be outlining a law forcing firms to hand details to police identifying who was using a computer or mobile phone at a given time. The Home Office says that the measure as part of the Counter-Terrorism and Security Bill will improve national security helping police and security services to pinpoint:

  • Organised criminals
  • Cyber-bullies and hackers
  • Terror suspects and child sex offenders communicating over the internet
  • Vulnerable people such as children using social media to discuss taking their own life

The proposals would assist police to locate suspects via a computer or mobile device’s individual Internet Protocol (IP) address. Currently internet service providers do not need to hold data showing which IP address was allocated to a device at a given time making it not always possible for police and security services to match individuals to internet use. The new law, however, would require Internet Service Providers to record people’s internet activity, including social media use, online browsing and online gaming for 12 months.

Mrs May said “This is a step but it doesn’t go all the way to ensuring that we can identify all the people we will need to.” To “ fully identify” everyone  she said that police would need power to access communication data as previously proposed in the Communication Data Bill , labelled by critics as the snooper’s charter- an attempt to bring in wide- ranging  web monitoring powers.

It seems to be accepted across parties that this specific technical change is welcomed as sensible. However if the Home Secretary sees this recommendation as a route back into the whole snooper’s charter she will find the way rocky and perhaps impassable.

Met Police Commissioner Sir Bernard Hogan –Howe stated that he believed the proposals to be a step in the right direction but added “My job is to help keep people safe. To get that balance between security and privacy is Parliament’s job.”

A spokesman for the campaign group Liberty said “There’s no problem with the targeted investigation of terrorist suspects including, where it requires, linking apparently anonymous communications to a particular person. But every government proposal of the last so many years  has been about blanket surveillance of the entire population…So forgive us if we look for the devil in the detail of this new bill.”

What can you legally do in Scotland at what age?

With 16 year olds being allowed to vote in the recent Scottish Independence Referendum I was interested to read an article containing information (last updated on 23 September 2014) about some of the things you can do at certain ages in Scotland- this list is not exhaustive and any opinions voiced are entirely my own.

From age 2 you must:

Pay a child fare on most flights.

At 3 you can:

Start pre-school education.

At 5 you can:

Start full-time education at ‘school commencement date’ (usually in August) if 5 by ‘appropriate latest date’ (usually by end of following February. In France and Spain children do not start compulsory schooling until 6 and in Sweden compulsory schooling does not start until a child is 7.

At 7 you can:

Take money out of a National Savings Account and buy and sell National Savings Certificates.

At 8 you can:

Be found guilty of a criminal offence. There has been argument that the age of criminal responsibility should be raised to 12 but at the moment it remains at 8. In England & Wales it is age 10.

At 11 you can:

Get a free Young Scot National Entitlement Card which makes available discounts in a range of shops and offers deals on certain services and travel.

At 12 you can:

Make a Will.

Consult a solicitor and take a case to court.

Be the subject of an Anti-social Behaviour Order.

Make a freedom of information request from a local authority.

Register as an organ donor without parental/guardian consent.

At 13 you can:

Be employed to do light work specified in and subject to the local authority bylaws where you live (e.g. your local newspaper shop to do a paper round).

At 14 you can:

Get a job on a Saturday for up to 5 hours and for no more than 2 hours on school days (not before 7am or after 7pm). During school holidays you can work an overall weekly limit of 25 hours. You should not work for more than 4 hours in one day without 1 hour break.

At 15 you can:

Work up to 8 hours per day and 35 hours per week during school holidays.

At 16 you can:

Get married.

Enter into a civil partnership.

Consent to lawful sexual intercourse. In Spain until recently the age of sexual consent was 13 but it has now been raised to 16. In Germany it is 14.

Apply for your own home through your local council.

Buy wine, beer, cider or perry to drink in a restaurant only with a meal.

Choose your own GP.

Leave school. If you are 16 between 1 March and 30 September you can leave after 31 May of that year and if you are 16 between 1 October and the last day of February you can leave at the start of the Christmas holidays in that school year.

Buy a National lottery ticket.

Drive a moped.

Join the armed forces, but not to train as an officer and you will also need parental consent if you are under the age of 18. You can apply from the age of 15 years 9 months. The UK is the only country in Europe and the only member of Nato which routinely recruits people under the age of 18.

Buy a pet-you can own a pet before you’re 16 but you can’t buy one yourself without a parent/guardian being present until you’re 16.

Join a ScotWest credit union.

At 17 you can:

Hold a licence to drive a car. In most other European countries it is 18. In Gibraltar it is 19.

Hold a private pilot’s licence.

Give blood.

At 18 you can:

Vote in a general election.

Stand for election as a local councillor, MP or MSP.

Serve as a juror.

Be tattooed.

Buy and be served alcohol. In the USA you cannot buy or be served alcohol until you are 21.

At 21 you can:

Stand in European parliamentary elections as an MEP.

Hold a licence to drive any vehicle including large goods and passenger-carrying vehicles.

Be sent to an adult prison.

Of course there are certain things under Scots law which you can do legally without any age restriction for example, choose any religion to follow, be employed as a performer, be called as a witness and make a complaint under the Equality Act. However you have to have “sufficient understanding” –that is a grasp of the consequences, a good appreciation of the issues and overall seem to be responsible-otherwise the authorities can intervene.

Certainly looking at these age “categories” is not just informative but raises questions. Are we sending our children to school too early , bogging them down with reading exercises instead of allowing them to play peacefully in a sandpit? Should the age of criminal responsibility be raised from 8 ? Is it fair to label children as criminals at such a young age? Can we justify recruiting 16 year olds to our armed forces ? Lets face it at 16 young people are banned from buying the most violent films and video games. Food for thought.

Book Review – The President’s Hat by Antoine Laurain

Last week our book club met to chat about The President’s Hat by Antoine Laurain. This was my book suggestion. It is a charming fable about the power of a hat that takes the reader on a roller-coaster ride through French life in the Mitterrand years and it proved to be a popular choice with the group.

In November 1986 , 5 years into Francois Mitterrand’s 16 years reign as President of France , an ordinary accountant Daniel Mercier treats himself to a “bachelor evening” while his wife and son are away. Sitting in a restaurant indulging in oysters and a splendid bottle of Pouilly-Fuisse, Daniel can hardly believe his eyes when President Mitterrand and two of his associates sit down to eat at the table next to him.

After the presidential party leaves Daniel discovers that the President has left behind his black felt hat. Daniel perhaps emboldened by the wine he has drunk walks out of the restaurant wearing it. But this is no ordinary hat. Confidence that Daniel did not know he possessed soon comes out in unexpected ways. He criticises a superior at a meeting and gets promoted.

The hat is passed along by mishap and soon finds a new female owner, Fanny Marquant ,who is trapped in a long and unfulfilling love affair with a married man. When wearing the hat Fanny sees that being the other woman is not full of romance and secret meetings and she has the clarity to end her affair. She realises that the hat has given her this insight and that in turn she must pass the hat on to someone else.

The iconic item of headgear plays with the life of two further characters, a retired perfumer who rediscovers his genius and a ghastly right wing bore who suddenly becomes aware that all his friends are ghastly right wing bores, stops reading Le Figaro and starts reading Liberation. The hat changes the fortunes of all who possess it and eventually returns to its original owner in a unique way.

Can a hat change people’s destiny? Is this or is this not an allegory of power? While we wrestled with these questions we all agreed that we enjoyed the details of the book. Laurain captures each character quickly in a clever, colourful style with many subtle meanings. The short novel is shot through with a delicious sense of humour recreating vividly the everyday life of an era, being very much a hymn to la vie Parisienne in the 1980s.

That said the novel can simply be appreciated for its originality and fabulistic narrative. It acts as a reminder that many of life’s most important events can be the result of tiny details that shape our future in unexpected ways.

74% of Britons Admit They Didn’t Change the Locks after Their Last Move

Experts have confirmed that buying or selling a house is one of life’s major stresses. An in-depth study of 2000 adults commissioned earlier this year by discovered a large percentage found the hassles of moving home were greater than the tensions experienced when losing a job, becoming a parent or planning a wedding.

Certainly moving home has its anxious moments. You find a house and have a buyer for your flat and that is often the easiest part. Buying and selling at the same time often means that you have to deal with two sets of estate agents, two sets of solicitors and different lenders. Issues may come up with the paperwork which could derail the whole process. You don’t want to get too attached to the place you are buying in case everything falls through .On the other hand you worry about your new home as it is the biggest purchase of your life- yet you have only seen it once and you would have spent longer deliberating over what shoes to buy. And then there is the packing up, the actual removal , the unpacking and looking for the kettle.

In the midst of all this with so much to organise and remember it is easy to overlook some important tasks, chief among which is getting your locks changed when you move into your new property. A recent survey by Keytec Locksmiths has shown that less than 30% of homeowners change their locks after moving home potentially leaving them vulnerable to break-ins by other keyholders.

There is little doubt that a home insurance claim may be at risk of being turned down if a spare set of keys was used by a previous owner or tradesman to commit burglary as generally speaking there must be clear signs of breaking and entering in order for a claim to be valid. And it is also not just the insurance implications to think about –there is also the possibility that you could be putting yourself and your family in danger as even if you completely trust the sellers there really is no telling how many sets of keys they have given to friends and relatives or lost over the years and forgotten about.

According to Home Office statistics you are almost twice as likely to be broken into in the first year after moving house and nearly three times as likely in comparison to occupiers who have been in their house for over 10 years and although the Office of National Statistics shows the number of recorded burglaries has been gradually falling year on year for the past decade, nonetheless it is one of the most commonly recorded crimes.

Compared to the overall cost of buying a property the cost of changing locks is likely to be very modest and can provide security and peace of mind. With so many expenses and arrangements to think about in any house move it is hardly surprising that home security is not always prioritised in the way it should be. As said before for most people buying a house is the largest purchase they will ever make so it seems sensible to spend a few more pounds just for the peace of mind of knowing who has a key to it.

What do you think? Did you get the locks changed after your last move?

Surrogacy and the Law

As an undergraduate I studied Forensic Medicine. One of the topics we covered was the legal issues surrounding surrogacy and so it was with interest that I read a recent BBC report which pointed out that the number of registered surrogacies in the UK has risen from just 83 in 2010 to a projected figure of more than 200 this year.  Surrogacy is legal in Scotland but subject to many complexities.

A surrogate mother is a woman who carries a child by virtue of an arrangement to do so. Common scenarios might be a married couple encountering difficulties in conceiving or giving birth naturally or a family member agreeing to carry a baby for her sister who has had a hysterectomy. There are two types of surrogacy, partial and full. Partial surrogacy involves the surrogate mother’s egg being fertilized with the intended father’s sperm. In full surrogacy there is no genetic link between the surrogate mother and child.

A surrogacy agreement will be entered into between the parties wanting to be parents and the surrogate mother. The arrangement must be made before the mother begins to carry the child and is formulated with a view to handing over the child to the prospective parents after the child is born. It is illegal to advertise for a surrogate or for a surrogate to advertise her services. No money or other benefit, other than reasonable expenses, must be given or received by either party.

Legally, however, surrogacy arrangements are unenforceable. Ultimately the surrogate mother has the legal right to keep the child when it is born and if the intended parents decide they do not want the child then they can walk away even if a contract has been signed. Few could have missed the story of baby Gammy, born to a Thai surrogate. The baby had Down’s syndrome and was allegedly left behind by the Australian “commissioning couple”. There is nothing to prevent the same situation happening in Scotland.

A recent English case highlighted further difficulties. A heterosexual couple wanted a child but the female of the couple had had a hysterectomy so a friend agreed to act as the surrogate using the male’s sperm and her own egg. A baby girl was born, handed over to the couple but three months later the couple split up. The woman left the home and took the baby with her.  But the surrogate mother was legally the child’s mother and the man in the couple was legally the child’s father. The woman of the couple had no legal relationship with the child whatsoever. This would equally apply in Scotland: the woman of the couple would have no parental rights and responsibilities, with no right to have the child living with her whereas the surrogate mother would be responsible for regulating the child’s residence and be obligated to financially support the child.

Clearly legal advice is crucial to ensure the relationship between the child and its intended parents is given the correct legal standing .Parenthood can only be transferred to the intended parents through a court order. An application for a parental order must be made within the first 6 months of a child’s life. In Scotland application is made to the Court of Session or the Sheriff Court in the place the child resides. The applicants must be husband and wife, civil partners of each other or two people who are living together in “an enduring family relationship.” The child must be living with the applicants at both the time of the application and the time of the making of the order. One of the applicants must be domiciled in the UK. The court must be satisfied that the surrogate mother or anyone else who is a parent of the child but not one of the applicants freely consents to the making of the order.

Why A Power Of Attorney Is A Good Idea

Last December a new campaign was launched across Glasgow to raise awareness about the importance of having a Power of Attorney.NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde and Glasgow City Council joined forces with Alzheimer Scotland and Scottish Care to highlight the need to “Start the Conversation” with family members about putting a Power of Attorney in place.

Every year thousands of people in Scotland lose capacity-it could be an accident, a head injury, a stroke or on-going progressive illness. Such occurrences are not age prescriptive. The only way you can plan for your future is to appoint an Attorney who can make decisions for you when you are unable to do so for yourself. Anyone over the age of 16 can make a Power of Attorney.

So what is a Power Of Attorney? It is a written legal document giving someone else authority to take actions or make decisions on your behalf. You choose who you want to act as your Attorney and what powers you want the Attorney to have. The deed can cover both financial and welfare provisions.

The financial provisions can include power to purchase and sell heritable property, power to operate bank accounts, power to claim and receive all pensions, benefits, allowances etc. There are many other powers which can be included or left out as appropriate, depending on your circumstances. Welfare powers can include power to decide where you should live, to have access to your personal information, to consent or withhold consent to medical treatment.  Again there are other powers that can be specified to meet your individual needs. The deed can be limited to cover a certain transaction or to cover only a specified period of time.

You can appoint anyone you wish to be your Attorney e g family member, friend or solicitor. Importantly you should appoint only someone you trust- whoever you feel comfortable with dealing with your affairs.

To become effective and to allow your Attorney to act on your behalf the Power of Attorney must be registered with the Office of Public Guardian which supervises all such appointments.  It is therefore possible for a Power of Attorney to be drawn up now and put aside to be registered in the future when appropriate. Further provision can be made in the Power of Attorney that it must not be registered unless a doctor certifies that you are unable to manage your own affairs.

In a different context a Power of Attorney could be used to help in everyday life. For example couples may decide to grant each other Power of Attorney if one partner spends a lot of time working overseas. Someone may grant a Power of Attorney to a trusted friend or professional to complete a transaction for example a house purchase settling when the grantee is out of the country. A student may grant a Power of Attorney in favour of their parents while they explore the world during a gap year.

One last point to note if you have not granted a Power of Attorney in advance and you do lose capacity then the courts have to appoint someone to act as your guardian. There are processes by which family members can apply to be granted these powers but it is a long and expensive process requiring a court hearing.


Small Print Hides A Multitude of Sins

I am a customer of a major Scottish bank. I logged on recently to its online service and was told that the terms and conditions had been changed and that I had to “accept” new conditions if I wanted to proceed.  I scrolled down pages of turgid text before finding “accept”. As a lawyer I thought “I should read this”: as a member of the human race I thought “I just want to see my balance, just click “accept”. Human nature prevailed.

All of us at some point will have signed up to a bank account or credit card or booked flights online and I am sure that many people do not read the small print. However, when clicking “accept” you are agreeing a contract on exactly those terms with the company. Granted it is rarely feasible to read the terms and conditions at the moment of agreeing to them and it is rarer still to have any negotiating power to change the conditions. The consumer protection industry recognizes this and there is legislation in place to ensure that even contracts which have not been drafted or negotiated between both parties must still be “fair”.

However it is precisely the power and activity of the consumer protection industry  which has brought about the prevalence of terms and conditions ,no doubt  with the laudable aim of enabling the purchaser of a product or service to know in advance what he is getting. But, in practice  providers of goods and services have seized the opportunity to include disclaimers for every kind of incompetence they are capable of perpetuating and to sneak into such agreements a host of hidden charges.

With this is mind I would urge that a level of caution be applied to small print.  In an article he wrote some years ago our Chairman described the ignoring of small print as “Voluntary Consumer Blindness” (VCB). We chose not to “see” the small print and by introducing certain unfavourable terms and conditions many companies are hoping VCB will prevail.  VCB may save  the mind -numbing boredom of analysing the terms and conditions but you may also be paving the way for a company to claim extra monies from you.

So when opening a bank account please check out the charges, make sure terms which are being offered are set out in writing , look at notice periods and check that any trivial breach does not change all the rates and charges.  When booking flights on line check costs for additional baggage, charges for losing boarding passes and any compensation due for late or cancelled flights.

If I can advise you regarding the terms and conditions of any contract you may be involved in please call Paul Neilly on 0141 552 3422 or email me on